Can you cool a pie in the fridge?

In this article, we will answer the question “Can you cool a pie in the fridge?”, what’s the shelf-life of different types of pie, can you freeze a pie, can you leave a pie at room temperature overnight, and how to make pumpkin pie.

Can you cool a pie in the fridge?

Yes, you can cool your pie in the fridge. Let your freshly baked pie keep at room temperature for 30 minutes or until it reaches room temperature. Refrigerate your custard pie for a good 2 hours and your fruit pie for approx. 4 hours before eating. 

Cooling your pie in the fridge will allow its filling to be set so you can cut through it easily. Do not cut the pi right away. Leave it undisturbed on the counter for about 5 minutes before slicing.  If you like your pie warm, nuke it in the oven preheated at 300F for about 15-20 minutes.

What’s the shelf-life of different types of pie?

If the pie was stored correctly and was made with the freshest ingredients possible, it will stay good days after the date on the label. Fruit pie stays good for about 2-3 days in the fridge and 6-8 months in the freezer past the labeled date. 

Other types of pie such as cream pie, custard pie, pumpkin pie, quiche, and pot pie also have the same shelf life. Do not wait to freeze the pie until its shelf-life in the refrigerator times out. The initial quality of the pie before freezing affects its shelf-life in the freezer. 

Can you freeze a pie?

Yes, you can freeze a pie. However, not every type of pie freezes well. Some freeze better than others due to their composition. 

For example, freezing pumpkin pie, fruit pie, and pecan pie are encouraged but it is not recommended to freeze mousse pie, custard pies, and meringue pies.

Can you leave a pie at room temperature overnight?

Yes, you can leave a pie at room temperature overnight. But it depends on what type of pie are we talking about. If the pie contains dairy ingredients such as mousse or cream, it is not safe to leave it overnight.  

However, fruit pie can keep at room temperature overnight without any threat to its safety. Make sure to cover the fruit pie with plastic wrap.

How to store pecan pie to prolong its shelf-life?

Once baked, plan on refrigerating the pie within 2 hours, or else it will become a haven for harmful bacteria.  It is equally important to let the pie cool down before refrigerating.

Wrapping and refrigerating pie while it is still warm will lead to condensation. The moisture from condensation will collect on the inner side of the pie container and get absorbed into it.

Your best bet is to cover the pie in a sealing pie plate. If you do not want to bother, use a plate or foil/plastic wrap as a makeshift cover. Refrain from suffocating the pie by wrapping it in plastic or foil too tightly. 

It will de-shape the pie and ruin its visible appeal. A plate turned on top of the pie is a good choice unless fridge space is an issue. Ideally, you should keep the pecan pie near the back of the fridge, where it is the coldest.

How long does pecan pie last?

Properly wrapped and consistently refrigerated pecan pie will last up to 4 days in the fridge. It is recommended to finish your pie as soon as possible to prevent it from going bad or degrading in quality. 

If you do not intend to eat the pie within 2 days of refrigeration, it’s ideal if you freeze it. Correctly frozen pecan pie will stay fresh for at least a couple of months. 

How to freeze pecan pie?

To prevent the pecan pie from getting soggy, wrap it in plastic two times. Then put it in a heavy-duty freezer bag. This will preserve the freshness of the pecan pie and prevent freezer burn by completely blocking the harsh freezer air.

Better yet, you can slice the pecan pie before freezing and freeze the individual slices after double-wrapping them in plastic. This will allow you to defrost as many slices of pie as you want at once. 


In this article, we answered the question “Can you cool a pie in the fridge?”, what’s the shelf-life of different types of pie, can you freeze a pie, can you leave a pie at room temperature overnight, and how to make pumpkin pie.



What was missing from this post which could have made it better?

Leave a Comment